the
reviews
Exposé Magazine #21 (USA) Phaeton is three German
gents, who skillfully blend about three-quarters classic Tangerine Dream
with about one-quarter prog rock influence thrown in for good measure. 2000 (c) Phil Derby / Exposé Magazine progVisions (Mexico) Germany is a country that has always been directly related to avant-garde and electronic music thanks to groups and musicians like Popol Vuh, Tangerine Dream, Kraftkwerk or Klaus Schulze. However, most people think of this electronic style as something that belongs to the seventies. A terrible mistake! It still exists nowadays and it is as interesting and revolutionary as it was 25 years ago. A proof of this is Foreign Spaces, a band that should be taken seriously in the world of electronic music. Although they are not the most innovative band (their style is mainly based on a more classic sound), they are indeed an excellent heir to the classic German bands in the electronic tradition. Foreign Spaces is a trio that includes Georg Reiter, Lothar Lubitz and Christian Feher on keyboards and electronic percussion. Phaeton is their fourth album, after UFO Breakfast (1995), Being Creature (1996) and Dark Star (1997). It is an interesting collection of instrumental works that were recorded between 1998 and 2000. The sound created by Foreign Spaces reminds of the classic Tangerine Dream (Ricochet, Stratosfear) and also includes some electronic percussion more in the style of Kraftwerk on pieces like “Blue Stream”. The use of digital and analog synthesisers provides this band with a blend of sonorities that come from different time periods (analog for the seventies and digital for the eighties and nineties). Contrary to other electronic bands, their style is not ambient, thanks to the use of rhythm changes and varied moods. Pieces like “Phaeton I-Planet” (17:39) and “Phaeton II-Lifeforms” (21:19) are two of the most impressive parts of the album, both of them full of different atmospheres and keyboard ambiences. The length of these tracks only confirms how impressive electronic music can be. The use of minimalism is not part of Foreign Spaces’ music. However, “White Sunset” is the exception, given that it is actually a nice track in the style of Klaus Schulze. Put special interest in pieces like “Moonless” and “Spheric Architecture”, two delicate themes with excellent musical arrangements. The album closes with “Phaeton III-Utopia”, a majestic song of great beauty. Another important detail that I have to mention is the artwork: the cover is excellent, its images do fit perfectly with electronic music. Moreover, the album includes a poster with the whole artwork. Great point! To sum it up, it is important to say that the music of Foreign Spaces is refined electronic music with a seventies feeling. Their last album, Phaeton, is an interesting album that will certainly please most fans of electronic music. If you are interested in this musical genre, get it, you will find it a quality purchase. Enrique Gómez, December 2000, Synth Music Direct (UK) Never a dull moment when a new CD from Foreign Spaces arrives. Characterised by inconsistency, their previous offerings have when it all "came together" presented some of the most sublime and infectious EM to be found anywhere. Witness the incredible closing 5 minutes of 'Dark Star Part 1', a piece I still revisit with anticipation and awe. So now we have 'Phaeton', and though only 3 letters away from TD's classic album this is nothing like that style, in fact one of the characteristics of FS is that they sound like no other band on the scene today. The opener 'Phaeton I - Planet' typifies their unique style, with gripping sequences adorned with overtly melodic lines which dominate the mix. After an extensive 7 minute rhythmic section the track takes a breather with a pleasing ambient pastiche. Hit the 10 mark and the track then presents its full repertoire of melodic sequencing and a beautiful lead line picked out on their trademark searing synth vox. It mutates, ebbs and flows for the remainder of the piece presenting different angles on the same theme. It's the 4th time I've heard this piece, and true to form suddenly this has clicked - it's yet again another FS "classic moment" with the most infectious melodies. 'Blue Stream' glides in on a wave of classic sequencing then another impressive theme starts up which makes all the right statements. The piece is punctuated by those slightly quirky falling note interludes, which again are so characteristic, before again setting off on its soaring flight. If I could make any criticism it's that I'd like FS to let the track flow slightly more. Such is their enthusiasm to cram in the variation and entertainment it can be a little counter- productive at times, but even so by any benchmark this is a fine piece. 'Moonless' consists of a syncopating sequence and a relatively understated main theme, while 'Silver Glider' opens with massed synth chords before yet another superbly constructed theme hits home. This is quality. 'Phaeton II - Lifeforms', the longest piece at 21:19, follows and its size and position make it very much the pivotal track of the album. Ambient resonance and effects introduce the section before crashing percussives really get the ears flapping. The complexity of construction is fascinating as theme upon theme emerges only to be usurped by another. At 3 mins a more rhythmic section takes over and listen out for the detailed inflexion of the sequence notes, very clever and it really keeps you wondering what's going to spring out of the mix next. Again the only comment I'd make is that, initially, the stop/start nature does take some getting used to but familiarity makes it sit more comfortably. Fade at 6 minutes (yes, were only at 6 mins - what the next 15 mins bring God only knows!) to a more sedated section which eventually morphs into weird effects, then an arpeggiating sequence breaks through and swings from speaker to speaker. And amazingly it just gets better and better, with the closing themes a melodic delight. 'Spheric Architecture' features the most sublime motif to open and close the piece, sandwiching a meandering theme which has its own merits. The whole piece is underpinned by a choppy yet delicate sequence which briefly breaks through from time to time. 'Artificial Encounter' adopts a more laid back stance, with the ubiquitous flutey synth accompanied by more fine cameo synth roles. 'White Sunset' is a beautiful atmospheric piece, and just listen to the wonderful textures which FS create here. Instantly recognisable and immensely pleasing, this (the shortest piece at 3.44) is much more than the obligatory "space filler". Finally we are presented with the third part of the title track, subtitled 'Utopia'. Harpsichord sequencing gives it a slightly formal air, but the strong melody and fleeting drum beat offsets this with more contemporary leanings. A strong finish. You already get the idea that this is a fine album - it's probably the most consistent FS outing to date. Fans of their melodically rhythmic and very individual style will find that it has been worth the wait. (GG) Graham Getty, June 2000 New Horizons (UK) Foreign Spaces first came
into existence, back in 1979, after Georg Riter came across a an old
synthesiser during a rehearsal session and became fascinated by the
possibilities of such an instrument. He quickly decided to form his
own band and began playing his own style of electronic music with a
variety of friends until, in 1994, he formed a stable writing partnership
with Christian Feher. Together they released three albums; 'UFO Breakfast'
(1995), 'Being Creature' (1996) and 'Dark Star' (1997). A further member,
Lothar Lubitz, joined the duo in 1999 - just in time for this album, the
band's fourth, 'Phaeton'. At a time when there are many bands climbing onto the electronic bandwagon, Foreign Spaces work hard to ensure that quality not quantity is a major goal. This goes a long way towards explaining why there has been a three year gap between 'Phaeton' and their previous release. Having written enough material to fill two CD's, they have endeavoured to hone the music down to more manageable proportions and, with judicious and careful editing of what was to be included, they have certainly managed to produce a top quality product. Science fiction has proven to be a frequent source of inspiration in this arena, and this album is no exception. While each of the band's previous albums has had an underlying story, this project has proved the most ambitious to date looking, as it does, at different aspects of an as yet 'undiscovered' tenth planet in our own solar system. The very nature of this album means that I am not going to attempt to tackle the tracks individually as it would be very hard to meaningfully describe each one in turn. The main body of the album is taken up with the tracks 'Phaeton I' and 'Phaeton II' (which run for 17'39" and 21'19" respectively). The overall feel of these tracks is strong and majestic and, while there is a tendency in both of them to use repetitive themes to provide the underlying heartbeat, the foreground sound is constantly moving and evolving, keeping the overall feel of the music fresh and bright. This constant change and development keeps the listener constantly on guard for whatever may be coming next. The remaining tracks however are far more than simple bridging pieces and are rich in detail and also full of atmosphere. There is rich variety to be found within them, sometimes the music comes across as being heavily symphonic, while at other times the band show themselves to be masters of space rock or at producing simple ambient pieces. In terms of the pace of the tracks we witness further evidence of variety as we constantly thread our way through upbeat fast moving sections to slow dreamy sequences that have an almost narcotic quality. All in all this is a fine album for anyone who has ever enjoyed listening to keyboard based instrumental music and, for those who have never really given electronic music a chance before, let me say that this could prove to be an excellent point at which to dive in and test the water. This album really does run through a whole range of styles and with the combination of strong playing and superb production is well worth checking out. Simon, 28th
January 2001, This
is the fourth Foreign Spaces release but their first on Invisible Shadows.
Once again the band, consisting of Georg Reiter, Lothar Lubitz and Christian
Feher, have a heavily sequencer-based style which, by hint of some
impressive production work, manages to sound quite epic with just a hint
of mystery creeping in, as if what we perceive as real were looked at
through a distorting mirror, tipping reality off it's axis, a feeling that
is further emphasised by the excellent sci-fi style cover artwork. Carl Jenkinson, 2000 Krautrocknet.com
(UK) Ambient
Visions (USA) Jim Brenholts,
author of "Tracks Across the Universe: A Chronology of Ambient and
Electronic Music", 3rd January 2002, This album begins with a
symphonic and well orchestrated long track: Phaeton I - Planet.
This track has a big sound universe with nice sequencers and fantastic
stereo surround effects. The other eight tracks on this CD are all
quite melodic and have the same beautiful and big universe as the first
track. Rey, May 2001 Background Magazine
#76 (NL) SummaryWith three other titles under their belt, this the .... fourth with recordings from 1998-2000. The musicThe album opens with Phaeton I - Planet. Over seventeen minutes of Tangerine Dream oriented electronic music (and in a good way) with plenty of high. Lots of repetition in the melody lines, giving the music is a rather relaxed feel. The sound does get fuller and fuller, but continues to be rather spacey. The end sounds a bit sad in a way notwithstanding the long high sounds on the keyboards. Kind of a wailing effect. Blue Stream has a bit of everything. It opens well with strong loop and over that lots of variation. The track has both some mellow, some screamy and some triumphant aspects. After a dreamy but percussive opening Moonless has quiet subdued sequencing and again a lot fof high in the music. The music has something of desert music, but the melodies are bit boring. Lighter and more optimistic is Silver Glider. The melody is okay, but it is based on this one single theme. On the other hand, the long Phaeton II - Lifeforms has plenty of those, strung together as so many hams. Actually this track is really fragmentary, some themes are okay, some are not which is a shame. The bad themes always win. Again nice melodies on Spheric Architecture, but the sound of the album is by now familiar. Little is added to it. Or maybe the guitar like opening to Articifical Encounter, which has some melodic aspects of Twelfht Night's Creepshow (must be accidental). A bit bouncy this one. After the spooky White Sunset we conclude with the strong Phaeton III - Utopia has a strong melody, is concise and is really a electronic composition. ConclusionAlthough the level of Tangerine Dream is never obtained, there is nothing really simple or easy about the music of Foreign Spaces. In fact, this is rather serious spacey electronic music, not original anything, but certainly not bad either. Compared to Imagination-Pictures-Music this album is much more consistent, although the high points of IPM I think I liked better. What I did and do lack in the music is a bit emotion. The triggered drums and the choice of sounds make the music come over quite cold. Jurriaan Hage, July 2001 This is a strong showing by three German gents, who skillfully blend about three-quarters classic Tangerine Dream with about one-quarter prog rock influence thrown in for good measure. At the heart of the CD are two long synth-driven passages, "Phaeton I" and "Phaeton II." Each has a variety of twists and turns, and although it is largely familiar territory from those who came before, it is well done. A very TD-like sequence and playful synth lead line opens "Phaeton I - Planet" for a few minutes, then some obligatory big synth chords come in for a bit, followed by a very nice, laid-back, dreamy passage. It is the mixture of these different themes, flowing smoothly into one another, which make this a step above the cookie-cutter approach of some Teutonic enthusiasts. Though the sounds and musical ideas aren't the most original, they are combined in interesting and pleasurable ways. The music is generally very positive and upbeat. Sandwiched between the lengthy parts of the title track are several shorter ones. "Blue Stream" seems a bit over the top, although some will no doubt enjoy its melodramatic, majestic flavour. "Moonless" is much more subtle, yielding better results. Playful melodies bounce off light sequencing and electronics. "Silver Glider" again heads into somewhat histrionic territory, but with classic synth chords that I just can't resist, even though it will come across as total cliché to some. Next comes "Phaeton II - Lifeforms," the 20-plus minute centerpiece. Long, low washes of synth pads make a beautiful beginning, giving way to a much more freeform style like classic Yes or other 70s prog. Lots of different things happening here, which you'll either like a lot or find a bit of a muddled mess. I found it a largely effective combination of Berlin school and progressive rock. This is complex, deliberate music, not the long improvisational style of some in the genre. A sort of reprise of "Phaeton I" makes an appearance to finish off this track. Four shorter tracks round things out, ranging from the playful "Spheric Architecture" to the light, airy "Artificial Encounter." The low key, ever-so-slightly darker "White Sunset" makes for a nice change of pace before "Phaeton III - Utopia" ends things in more traditional synth style. (c) Phil Derby, 2000 Vor langer Zeit wurde einmal ein Begriff für ideenreiches Schaffen geprägt: Kreativität - ich glaube, dieser Begriff stammt von den Einwohnern des Planeten PHAETON, irgendwo in den fremden Räumen (FOREIGN SPACES) unseres Universums. Deren Herrscher Georg Reiter und Christian Feher haben was zu sagen. Nein, kein unwirkliches Blabla. Vielmehr richtige Messages aus längst versunkenen Kulturlandschaften, die einstmals von Heroen wie Klaus Schulze und Tangerine Dream beherrscht wurden. Ernsthafte Impulse im Jahre 2000 kommen aber von PHAETON! Selten ist es der Fall - ich schreibe das des öfteren, aber ich schreibe auch nur dann, wenn es mir auffällt -, dass mir eine CD so richtig die Gänsehaut über den Rücken jagt. Insbesondere dann, wenn sie von Spannungsbögen lebt, wie man sie nur sehr selten erlebt hat. Erinnerungen an epochale Werke, wie z.B. Tangerine Dreams TANGRAM können da wieder aufleben. Warme Musik, kein digitales Geflirre und Süßholzgeraspel, nein, richtige Musik! Und wer da noch ruft, dass analoge Synthesizer einfach wärmer als die digitalen Kollegen klingen würden, der möge sich doch PHAETON antun - hier. Rein technisch betrachtet haben wir eine erstklassige Produktion vor uns liegen, die besonders von den Klängen der beiden verwendeten JD-800 und dem JD-990 von Roland lebt, ergänzt durch (so nehme ich mal einfach an) Lead-Lines des einzig wirklichen analogen Jupiter-6 aus gleichem Hause. Dazu etwas Flächiges vom D-50, etwas schlagkräftiges vom R-8M und den Rest vom Rave-O-Lution 309 aus dem Hause Quasimidi. Man könnte meinen, FOREIGN SPACES wären Roland-Endorser. Eigentlich müssten die Roland-Messe-Leute diese beiden Musiker für ihre Präsentationen engagieren, denn was hier aus dem Lautsprecher kommt, kann sich nicht nur, nein, muss sich sogar hören lassen! Insbesondere das Titelstück PHAETON I - PLANET mit seiner Gesamtlänge von 17:39 Minuten hat es mir angetan. Werden solche "Endlosstücke" häufig langweilig, da die Spannungsbögen allzu lang gehalten zu werden pflegen, gelingt es FOREIGN SPACES hier wirklich, ein Gesamtkunstwerk hinzulegen. Oder bildlich gesprochen: haben die frühen Heroen Plakatwände mit zwei farbigen Quadraten gefüllt, so wurde hier auf gleicher Größe die berühmte Nachtwache gemalt, und das mit den frischesten Farben. Dabei haben Reiter und Feher es verstanden, eine Linie durch den Opener zu ziehen. Hier wirkt nichts zufällig oder aneinandergeklebt. Homogen sollte man neu definieren, um dieses Stück zu beschreiben. Für mich das absolute Highlight von PHAETON. Es folgen drei kürzere Stücke BLUE STREAM, MOONLESS und SILVER GLIDER. Das erste Stück bringt ein kleines Break zu PHAETON I, das zweite erinnert ein wenig an bessere Zeiten eines mit KS abgekürzten Künstlers, während SILVER GLIDER ein weiteres Break darstellt - wie gesagt im Gesamtkonzept von PHAETON. Dann das längste Stück der CD: PHAETON II -. LIFEFORMS. Auch hier ist eine schöne Mischung zustande gekommen, die nicht langweilig zu werden droht. Auch taucht nach ca. fünfeinhalb Minuten wieder dieser schöne weiche Flächenklang auf, den ich aus einem der JDs heraus vermute. Wenn dieser selbstprogrammiert sein sollte, dann ist dies allein ein weiteres Meisterwerk! Nach rund zehn Minuten baut sich wieder einer dieser tollen Spannungsbögen auf. Die LIFEFORMS beginnen sich zu gestalten. SPHERIC ARCHITECTURE ist ein Stück, das seinen Namen verdient hat, denn hier tun sich wirklich sphärische Klänge auf. Sehr schön, von einer arpeggioartigen Sequenz getragen, die sich zudem ständig verändert. ARTIFICIAL ENCOUNTER gleitet mit etwas unüblicher Sequenz dahin. Gibt es einen Stil, so ist es bei FOREIGN SPACES die Auswahl der teilweise fantastischen Sounds und die Art und Weise der Melodielinie. Sequenzen, Akkorde und dergleichen sorgen aber von Stück zu Stück immer wieder für Überraschungen, und das ist gut so. Und wenn dann der Übergang zu WHITE SUNSET fließend geschieht, dann ist das eine weitere Überraschung. Und es wird sphärisch, mystisch, eben wie der Untergang einer weißen Sonne. Verhallte Chor-Akkorde und eine subtile Basslinie dominieren diesen Sonnenuntergang, der dann schließlich in PHAETON III - UTOPIA ausklingt. Dieses Stück wirkt ein wenig wie Abschied vom fantastischen Planeten PHAETON und erinnert von der Instrumentierung ein wenig an das Ende von TANGRAM der eingangs erwähnten Tangerine Dream. Aber es passt hervorragend an dieser Stelle und verleitet mich, erneut die CD mit der Reise über den Planeten PHAETON zu starten. Ohne Zweifel haben wir hier tolle Musik, die nicht langweilig zu werden droht und die von den vielzitierten Spannungsbögen lebt. Hätte es Tangerine Dream nicht gegeben, so würde man heute wohl von Schlierseeer Schule sprechen müssen. Wer mit den TD von heute nichts anfangen kann, eine Vorliebe für warme Klangflächen und analogen Sequenzen hegt, darüberhinaus auch noch eine Abneigung zu Four-on-the-Floor-Beats (zumindest teilweise einmal) hegt und wirklich schöne Musik hören möchte, wer das Wort "Langeweile" mit Elektronischer Musik bislang gleichsetzte und eines besseren belehrt werden möchte, wer noch ein paar Mark für eine auch äußerlich von Georg Reiter und Lothar Lubitz hervorragend inszenierte CD erübrigen möchte, wer all dieses (oder wenigstens ein paar von diesen Punkten) will, der kommt an FOREIGN SPACES nicht vorbei! Stephan Dargel, März 2000 |
Phaeton > the credits > the reviews > Exposé Magazine (USA) > progVisions (Mexico) > Synth Music Direct (UK) > New Horizons (UK) > Sequences (UK) > Krautrocknet.com (UK) > Ambient Visions (USA) > GalaxyJoe (Denmark) > Background Magazine (NL) > The Axiom Of Choice (NL) > Groove Unlimited (NL) > Synrise (D) > the graphics > back to the works |